Friday, August 15, 2025
Smart Again
  • Home
  • Trending
  • Politics
  • Law & Defense
  • Community
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Smart Again
  • Home
  • Trending
  • Politics
  • Law & Defense
  • Community
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Smart Again
No Result
View All Result
Home Trending

Texas could lose political clout under Trump’s call for a new census

August 15, 2025
in Trending
Reading Time: 6 mins read
0 0
A A
0
Texas could lose political clout under Trump’s call for a new census
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


“Texas could lose political clout under Trump’s call for a new census that excludes undocumented immigrants” was first published by The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan media organization that informs Texans — and engages with them — about public policy, politics, government and statewide issues.

Sign up for The Brief, The Texas Tribune’s daily newsletter that keeps readers up to speed on the most essential Texas news.

WASHINGTON — As Texas moves to redraw its congressional map at the behest of President Donald Trump, the White House is pushing ahead on another proposal to safeguard GOP power in Washington that could have major implications for Texas.

Last week, Trump said he had ordered the Commerce Department to start working on a new census that does not count undocumented immigrants.

Excluding “people who are in our Country illegally,” as Trump declared on social media, would fulfill a longtime conservative priority and mark a reversal from the longstanding practice of counting all people residing in the United States, legally or not, in the once-a-decade headcount.

With an estimated 1.7 million undocumented immigrants living in Texas, the move could have major ramifications for the state’s political sway.

One of the main motivations for White House officials in pushing forward a new census is the potential to reallocate political power, including Electoral College votes, from Democrat-dominated states to ones controlled by Republicans, according to two people with knowledge of the effort who were granted anonymity to discuss internal deliberations they were not authorized to publicly speak about.

The White House also sees a new census as an opportunity to correct an overcount of people in predominantly blue states from the 2020 census, which they argue gave too much political power to Democratic strongholds.

The push comes as Texas’ GOP-controlled Legislature is attempting to overhaul the state’s congressional lines to net Republicans up to five more seats — a process left in limbo by Democratic lawmakers’ departure from the state. Blue states — including California, New York and Illinois — have threatened to retaliate by crafting new districts of their own that would kick Republican lawmakers out of power.

Trump’s census proposal is all but certain to face constitutional challenges and logistical hurdles, and it would require cooperation from the U.S. Census Bureau and its staff of largely apolitical career civil servants.

But in his seven months in office, Trump has shown an unparalleled ability to bend the levers of power to his will and push the norms that have restrained previous presidencies.

How does the census determine political power?

Planning a national census is a yearslong process that typically happens once per decade, generating population and demographic data that is used to determine how billions of federal dollars are allocated and how many seats each state gets in Congress. States receive the number of districts that correspond to their total population, so that the more people living in a state, the more representatives they get to send to the U.S. House.

The census headcount also dictates each state’s footprint in the Electoral College, which is used to decide presidential elections and is based on how many House members a state elects, plus their two senators. Texas, for example, has two senators and 38 House members, giving it a whopping 40 Electoral College votes.

This distribution has long been based on the total number of people living in a given state, irrespective of citizenship. Under the Trump-backed proposal, only those residing in the country legally would be counted.

Such a change would have ripple effects across the nation. States with higher undocumented populations could see some of their congressional districts redistributed to states with fewer undocumented residents.

It’s not immediately clear how this would change the country’s political balance. California, Texas, New York and Florida — a mix of red and blue states — are among those with the highest number of unauthorized immigrants, according to the Migration Policy Institute, a nonpartisan Washington-based think tank. Texas comes in at No. 2 behind California, with 1.7 million undocumented immigrants as of 2019, according to the think tank’s estimates.

Red states that are home to a disproportionate number of undocumented immigrants, like Texas and Florida, could see a decrease in their counted population, thwarting their political power and throwing a wrench in Republicans’ plans, some experts believe.

“I don’t understand how illuminating them is going to be advantageous to Republicans,” said Jennifer Van Hook, a sociology and demography professor at Pennsylvania State University.

But blue states, most notably California and New York, have seen a population exodus in recent years, primarily to Republican-controlled states. The Democrats’ top redistricting organization, the National Democratic Redistricting Committee, has said it expects to see California, New York, Illinois, Rhode Island and other blue states lose seats under the traditional apportionment that will follow the 2030 census.

Meanwhile, Texas, Florida, Arizona and Georgia could add districts thanks to their massive population growth, the NDRC predicts, noting that Texas could see a three-seat pickup.

Republicans are betting population increases in red states with large undocumented populations would outweigh the losses they can expect by not counting those undocumented residents.

Referring to an overcount of some Democratic states in the 2020 census, Vice President JD Vance asserted that if the Trump administration conducted a new census, “you’d have 10 additional Republican seats and 9 fewer Democrat seats,” forecasting states like Ohio and Florida could gain political clout.

But not everyone is convinced a new census that omits undocumented residents would benefit one party over the other.

Robert Warren, a demographer at the Center for Migration Studies, created hypothetical electoral maps for each census dating back to 1980 that did not count undocumented immigrants. His research found that excluding the undocumented population had little to no effect on how congressional districts are doled out.

“It wouldn’t shift enough seats to make any difference, and that’s been true for five straight censuses,” he said in an interview with The Tribune.

Constitutional and procedural concerns

Paul Mitchell, a redistricting expert working in California Democratic politics, believes that not counting all people who live in a particular state runs afoul of the 14th Amendment, which requires House seats to be allocated based on the “whole number of persons in each state.”

“The Constitution very clearly says that apportionment is determined by the number of people, not citizens,” he said.

If Trump’s plan is carried out, it is all but certain to face legal challenges.

Trump’s firing of the head of Bureau of Labor Statistics over poor job numbers he claimed were inaccurate has disturbed some demography experts, who worry about what it portends for the accuracy of any census data obtained through atypical means.

The president’s announcement said the new data would be calculated from “modern day facts and figures,” including “information gained from the Presidential Election of 2024.”

While it remains unclear exactly how this would work, Van Hook said there’s been a fast-growing push to carry out an “administrative record census.” This new type of count would use data from other federal agencies — such as tax records, Medicare records and other government databases — to create a model of the nation without a full-fledged census survey.

But these databases are complex and incomplete, potentially proving inaccurate. An administrative records census could “leave out a lot of people who are not in official record systems,” Van Hook said, including undocumented immigrants and “people who don’t really want to be found.”

Even if the accuracy met census standards, carrying out such a complex new project could prove difficult before the 2028 election.

“The Census Bureau is a giant aircraft carrier, and they have to turn everything around, and it takes them months and months and months and months to do that,” Van Hook said. “It doesn’t seem plausible.”

Some legislation has been proposed to ameliorate the concerns, or at least lay the legal groundwork for an unconventional quick-turn census.

A bill by Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, R-Georgia, would require a revamp of the census before the 2026 elections. It would also give the bureau latitude to obtain the data through any method approved by the commerce secretary, “including the use of sampling procedures and special surveys.”

Another proposal, the “Equal Representation Act,” would implement a citizenship question on the 2030 census and exclude non-citizens from being counted in the apportionment of House seats and Electoral College votes. A version of the bill passed the House last year with broad support from Texas Republicans but failed to advance in the Senate.

This article originally appeared in The Texas Tribune at https://www.texastribune.org/2025/08/13/texas-trump-census-exclude-undocumented-immigrants/.

The Texas Tribune is a member-supported, nonpartisan newsroom informing and engaging Texans on state politics and policy. Learn more at texastribune.org.

Read more

about this topic



Source link

Tags: callCensuscloutLosepoliticalTexasTrumps
Previous Post

Tribal nations scramble to save clean energy projects

Next Post

Why Trump thinks DC can’t govern itself

Related Posts

Why Trump thinks DC can’t govern itself
Trending

Why Trump thinks DC can’t govern itself

August 15, 2025
FDR Signs Social Security Act
Trending

FDR Signs Social Security Act

August 15, 2025
And Just Like That gives Carrie Bradshaw a weirdly perfect ending
Trending

And Just Like That gives Carrie Bradshaw a weirdly perfect ending

August 15, 2025
The Emasculation Of Trump Is Being Perfectly Executed By Governor’s Pritzker, Newsom, And Former House Rep. Adam Kinzinger.
Trending

The Emasculation Of Trump Is Being Perfectly Executed By Governor’s Pritzker, Newsom, And Former House Rep. Adam Kinzinger.

August 14, 2025
Manufactured Outrage Over Nova Scotia Wildfire Restrictions
Trending

Manufactured Outrage Over Nova Scotia Wildfire Restrictions

August 14, 2025
“Liberation Day”: Newsom calls for special election to make good on redistricting threat
Trending

“Liberation Day”: Newsom calls for special election to make good on redistricting threat

August 14, 2025
Next Post
Why Trump thinks DC can’t govern itself

Why Trump thinks DC can’t govern itself

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
How commerce became our most powerful tool against global poverty

How commerce became our most powerful tool against global poverty

April 12, 2025
Clyburn blasts GOP proposal to oust him from Congress

Clyburn blasts GOP proposal to oust him from Congress

August 7, 2025
Israel’s Gaza policy is viciously cruel — and strategically disastrous

Israel’s Gaza policy is viciously cruel — and strategically disastrous

August 7, 2025
Democrats accuse GOP of “weaponizing” FBI against Texas lawmakers

Democrats accuse GOP of “weaponizing” FBI against Texas lawmakers

August 7, 2025
Trump’s drops IVF promise, preferring to blame women for infertility

Trump’s drops IVF promise, preferring to blame women for infertility

August 8, 2025
Lisa Kudrow Inadvertently Channels A Certain MAGA Press Flack

Lisa Kudrow Inadvertently Channels A Certain MAGA Press Flack

August 14, 2025
“They stole an election”: Former Florida senator found guilty in “ghost candidates” scandal

“They stole an election”: Former Florida senator found guilty in “ghost candidates” scandal

0
The Hawaii senator who faced down racism and ableism—and killed Nazis

The Hawaii senator who faced down racism and ableism—and killed Nazis

0
The murder rate fell at the fastest-ever pace last year—and it’s still falling

The murder rate fell at the fastest-ever pace last year—and it’s still falling

0
Trump used the site of the first assassination attempt to spew falsehoods

Trump used the site of the first assassination attempt to spew falsehoods

0
MAGA church plans to raffle a Trump AR-15 at Second Amendment rally

MAGA church plans to raffle a Trump AR-15 at Second Amendment rally

0
Tens of thousands are dying on the disability wait list

Tens of thousands are dying on the disability wait list

0
Why Trump thinks DC can’t govern itself

Why Trump thinks DC can’t govern itself

August 15, 2025
Texas could lose political clout under Trump’s call for a new census

Texas could lose political clout under Trump’s call for a new census

August 15, 2025
Tribal nations scramble to save clean energy projects

Tribal nations scramble to save clean energy projects

August 15, 2025
FDR Signs Social Security Act

FDR Signs Social Security Act

August 15, 2025
And Just Like That gives Carrie Bradshaw a weirdly perfect ending

And Just Like That gives Carrie Bradshaw a weirdly perfect ending

August 15, 2025
Tom Cruise turned down Trump’s Kennedy Center honor

Tom Cruise turned down Trump’s Kennedy Center honor

August 15, 2025
Smart Again

Stay informed with Smart Again, the go-to news source for liberal perspectives and in-depth analysis on politics, social justice, and more. Join us in making news smart again.

CATEGORIES

  • Community
  • Law & Defense
  • Politics
  • Trending
  • Uncategorized
No Result
View All Result

LATEST UPDATES

  • Why Trump thinks DC can’t govern itself
  • Texas could lose political clout under Trump’s call for a new census
  • Tribal nations scramble to save clean energy projects
  • About Us
  • Advertise with Us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA
  • Cookie Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact Us

Copyright © 2024 Smart Again.
Smart Again is not responsible for the content of external sites.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Trending
  • Politics
  • Law & Defense
  • Community
  • Contact Us

Copyright © 2024 Smart Again.
Smart Again is not responsible for the content of external sites.

Go to mobile version