Monday, July 14, 2025
Smart Again
  • Home
  • Trending
  • Politics
  • Law & Defense
  • Community
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Smart Again
  • Home
  • Trending
  • Politics
  • Law & Defense
  • Community
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Smart Again
No Result
View All Result
Home Trending

Trump’s “McCarthy era” throwback: A promise to deport protesters

December 21, 2024
in Trending
Reading Time: 3 mins read
0 0
A A
0
Trump’s “McCarthy era” throwback: A promise to deport protesters
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


With President-elect Donald Trump promising to make mass deportation a top priority in 2025, one related campaign promise has fallen off the radar. During the campaign, Trump said several times that he would seek to deport pro-Palestinian protesters, which would be an obvious test of the new president’s willingness and ability to challenge long-established First Amendment rights. 

Trump’s Agenda 47, his official platform for the 2024 election, lays out 20 planks, including promises to seal the border, stage mass deportations of undocumented immigrants and end inflation. Tucked away in the 18th bullet point, however, is a promise to crack down on campus protesters: “DEPORT PRO-HAMAS RADICALS AND MAKE OUR COLLEGE CAMPUSES SAFE AND PATRIOTIC AGAIN,” it reads. 

That was hardly Trump’s only statement that appeared to support the potential deportation of American citizens.  He has also said he plans to end birthright citizenship, which is guaranteed under the 14th Amendment, and to deport entire families, including U.S. citizens, when a family includes undocumented immigrants.

Matt Cameron, an immigration lawyer at Cameron Micheroni & Silvia, told Salon that deportation has been used throughout U.S. history to threaten or punish political dissidents. Perhaps the most famous example was the activist and writer Emma Goldman, who had immigrated to America as a teenager but was deported to Russia under the Anti-Anarchist Act in 1919.

Seeking to deport someone based on political speech would almost certainly violate the First Amendment. That doesn’t mean the Trump administration won’t try it.

Cameron said he expects Trump and his allies to rely on a statute that allows for non-citizen U.S. residents to be deported if they are found to have engaged in “material support” for “terrorism” — a category that Cameron described as problematically broad — or to have their visas denied if they are found to have endorsed or supported “terrorist activity.”

From the late 19th century “all the way through the McCarthy era” of the 1950s, Cameron said, the immigration system was used to “threaten” political dissidents. 

An investigation by the Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University found that even government lawyers believed that removing people from the country based on their political speech would violate the First Amendment. But Cameron said that doesn’t mean the Trump administration won’t try it. Something as normal as a social media post or a visible presence at a high-profile protest could be used as potential evidence.

“I certainly believe them when they say they going to try this,” Cameron said. During the Trump era, he added, “We’re getting used to the idea that just because something is illegal doesn’t mean it won’t happen.”

For U.S. citizens, Cameron noted, any such proceedings would be more complicated. The Trump administration might seek to pursue a policy of “denaturalization,” a rare procedure under which someone is stripped of their citizenship. Although denaturalization was established in 1906, it is typically reserved for people accused of having obtained their citizenship through false statements.

Cameron said he suspects the Trump team may go after recently naturalized citizens, especially immigrants from Arab or Muslim countries, who express opposition to Israel’s war on Gaza or are critical of U.S. policy in the Middle East. There is no possible procedure for pursuing denaturalization en masse, Cameron added, and it could probably only be applied to movement leaders or high-profile individuals.

Esha Bhandari, the deputy director for speech at the American Civil Liberties Union, cautioned that while deporting U.S. citizens may prove too difficult even for Trump loyalists, the new administration could find other ways to stifle pro-Palestinian or anti-Israel protest.

Protesters could potentially be charged with crimes unrelated to their political speech, for instance, which could make foreign citizens here on visas immediately deportable. The government could also pressure colleges and universities to suspend protesters, which could end or endanger their student visas. Private individuals could also take anti-activism efforts into their own hands and file strategic lawsuits against public participation, or SLAPP suits, which be expensive for defendants even if the cases have no merit. 

“I think the point of these broad statements threatening pro-Palestinian activists on campus,” Bhandari said, “is to put people who might already be vulnerable because of their immigration status into a position where they will self-censor.”

Read more

about protests and the law

 



Source link

Tags: deporteraMcCarthypromiseprotestersthrowbackTrumps
Previous Post

The Worst, Most Important, Book I Read This Year

Next Post

Why ABC settled a case with Donald Trump they knew they would win

Related Posts

A Mass Murderer’s Night Of Horror
Trending

A Mass Murderer’s Night Of Horror

July 14, 2025
’15 Percent Of Calls Were Answered’: NBC Host Fact-Checks Kristi Noem On Flood Response
Trending

’15 Percent Of Calls Were Answered’: NBC Host Fact-Checks Kristi Noem On Flood Response

July 13, 2025
Tomorrow belongs to MAGA: Trump echoes Broadway’s most famous Nazi in chilling hype video
Trending

Tomorrow belongs to MAGA: Trump echoes Broadway’s most famous Nazi in chilling hype video

July 13, 2025
Gunman opens fire in KY church after wounding trooper, dies at scene
Trending

Gunman opens fire in KY church after wounding trooper, dies at scene

July 13, 2025
IT IS TIME TO TAKE ACTION AGAINST THE TRUMP JUSTICES AND THEIR ASSAULT ON AMERICAN LAWS AND VALUES.
Trending

IT IS TIME TO TAKE ACTION AGAINST THE TRUMP JUSTICES AND THEIR ASSAULT ON AMERICAN LAWS AND VALUES.

July 13, 2025
Trump defends Bondi as “selfish” MAGA continues Epstein freakout
Trending

Trump defends Bondi as “selfish” MAGA continues Epstein freakout

July 13, 2025
Next Post
Why ABC settled a case with Donald Trump they knew they would win

Why ABC settled a case with Donald Trump they knew they would win

Why is money so hard?

Why is money so hard?

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
How a House bill could let Trump label enemies as terrorists

How a House bill could let Trump label enemies as terrorists

November 20, 2024
Why is everyone crashing out?

Why is everyone crashing out?

June 29, 2025
“A huge net positive”: Controversial “Squid Game” character challenges Western representation ideals

“A huge net positive”: Controversial “Squid Game” character challenges Western representation ideals

December 31, 2024
“The Ugly Stepsister” rewrites “Cinderella” as a grotesque and darkly funny feminist fable

“The Ugly Stepsister” rewrites “Cinderella” as a grotesque and darkly funny feminist fable

April 18, 2025
This pro-Israel group keeps a  blacklist. Now it’s taking credit for deportations.

This pro-Israel group keeps a blacklist. Now it’s taking credit for deportations.

April 25, 2025
Wait, should I bother using antibacterial soap?

Wait, should I bother using antibacterial soap?

January 2, 2025
“They stole an election”: Former Florida senator found guilty in “ghost candidates” scandal

“They stole an election”: Former Florida senator found guilty in “ghost candidates” scandal

0
The Hawaii senator who faced down racism and ableism—and killed Nazis

The Hawaii senator who faced down racism and ableism—and killed Nazis

0
The murder rate fell at the fastest-ever pace last year—and it’s still falling

The murder rate fell at the fastest-ever pace last year—and it’s still falling

0
Trump used the site of the first assassination attempt to spew falsehoods

Trump used the site of the first assassination attempt to spew falsehoods

0
MAGA church plans to raffle a Trump AR-15 at Second Amendment rally

MAGA church plans to raffle a Trump AR-15 at Second Amendment rally

0
Tens of thousands are dying on the disability wait list

Tens of thousands are dying on the disability wait list

0
A Mass Murderer’s Night Of Horror

A Mass Murderer’s Night Of Horror

July 14, 2025
Bernie Sanders Calls Attention To Climate Change Amid Trump’s Chaos

Bernie Sanders Calls Attention To Climate Change Amid Trump’s Chaos

July 13, 2025
’15 Percent Of Calls Were Answered’: NBC Host Fact-Checks Kristi Noem On Flood Response

’15 Percent Of Calls Were Answered’: NBC Host Fact-Checks Kristi Noem On Flood Response

July 13, 2025
Tomorrow belongs to MAGA: Trump echoes Broadway’s most famous Nazi in chilling hype video

Tomorrow belongs to MAGA: Trump echoes Broadway’s most famous Nazi in chilling hype video

July 13, 2025
Gunman opens fire in KY church after wounding trooper, dies at scene

Gunman opens fire in KY church after wounding trooper, dies at scene

July 13, 2025
One year after assassination attempt, MAGA reiterates “God spared Trump”

One year after assassination attempt, MAGA reiterates “God spared Trump”

July 13, 2025
Smart Again

Stay informed with Smart Again, the go-to news source for liberal perspectives and in-depth analysis on politics, social justice, and more. Join us in making news smart again.

CATEGORIES

  • Community
  • Law & Defense
  • Politics
  • Trending
  • Uncategorized
No Result
View All Result

LATEST UPDATES

  • A Mass Murderer’s Night Of Horror
  • Bernie Sanders Calls Attention To Climate Change Amid Trump’s Chaos
  • ’15 Percent Of Calls Were Answered’: NBC Host Fact-Checks Kristi Noem On Flood Response
  • About Us
  • Advertise with Us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA
  • Cookie Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact Us

Copyright © 2024 Smart Again.
Smart Again is not responsible for the content of external sites.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Trending
  • Politics
  • Law & Defense
  • Community
  • Contact Us

Copyright © 2024 Smart Again.
Smart Again is not responsible for the content of external sites.

Go to mobile version